Educational Content Only: This page is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice, investment advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any financial product or security. Michael Gurr is a Medicare and retirement specialist, not a registered investment advisor. Through our office, clients have access to a team of specialized financial advisors who have tailored training specific to common retirement accounts and are built to work with folks 65+. For personalized investment, tax, or portfolio guidance, please consult a qualified financial advisor or tax professional.
They moved everything into CDs and savings accounts after 2008.
No more market exposure. No more watching statements fall.
The CDs protected them from every market decline that followed.
They were right about that.
What the CDs could not do was keep pace with inflation. Over 15 years, the purchasing power of their savings declined steadily while the dollar amounts stayed the same. They preserved the number. They eroded what it could buy.
They wanted safety and growth. They got one of them.
This page covers the real tradeoffs between the options that protect retirement savings from market losses — without pushing any of them. Advantages and limitations are presented equally for every option.
Why Safe Money Matters in Retirement
During the accumulation years, market risk is recoverable given time. In retirement, a market decline combines with withdrawals to create permanent damage to the portfolio base. A protected layer covering essential monthly expenses — without touching market-exposed assets during a downturn — means a bad market does not force the sale of investments at a loss to fund next month's bills.
That is the purpose of safe money in retirement. Not eliminating all risk. Protecting the essential income layer so the growth layer can be left alone long enough to recover.
The Options — Advantages and Tradeoffs
Savings Accounts and Money Market Accounts
Advantages
Fully liquid. FDIC insured up to limits. No surrender periods. Immediate access at any time. Rates can rise with the interest rate environment.
Tradeoffs
Rates have historically been low and often fall below inflation over long periods. Purchasing power of the principal erodes over a 20 to 30 year retirement. No guaranteed income stream for life. Entirely dependent on prevailing interest rates.
Best for: Emergency reserves, short-term cash needs, and the very near-term portion of an income plan.
Certificates of Deposit (CDs)
Advantages
FDIC insured. Predictable interest rate locked in for the term. No market exposure. Rates are often higher than savings accounts. Can be laddered to provide periodic access.
Tradeoffs
Fixed terms limit liquidity during the CD period. Early withdrawal typically triggers a penalty. Rates over long periods have often been below inflation, meaning real purchasing power can still erode. CDs mature and must be reinvested, introducing reinvestment risk when rates change.
Best for: Short-term safe money, laddering cash flow needs over a defined period, and near-term income with full principal protection.
Fixed Indexed Annuities
Advantages
Principal cannot decline due to market performance. Participation in index-linked growth up to a cap provides some upside. Tax-deferred growth. Can include an income rider for guaranteed income later.
Tradeoffs
Growth is limited compared to direct market investment. Surrender periods (typically 5 to 10 years) limit access to the full balance in early years, though most allow annual withdrawals up to a set percentage penalty-free. Not FDIC insured — backed by the financial strength of the issuing insurance company. Crediting methods can be complex and require careful review.
Best for: Retirees wanting principal protection with some growth potential, comfortable with reduced liquidity during the surrender period. Not appropriate as the entire retirement portfolio.
Guaranteed Income Annuities
Advantages
Predictable guaranteed income for life or a defined period, regardless of market conditions or longevity. Removes the risk of outliving the income from that portion of the plan. Simplifies income planning. Survivor options available to protect a spouse.
Tradeoffs
Money committed to guaranteed income is generally not available as a lump sum. Once income begins, it typically cannot be reversed. A fixed monthly payment may lose purchasing power over time without a cost-of-living feature. Early death may mean less received than the amount committed, though survivor features can address this.
Best for: Covering the essential income portion of monthly expenses not already covered by Social Security or pension. Not appropriate for money that may be needed as a lump sum or kept fully liquid.
The Safe Money Layer in Context
The goal of a retirement income plan is not all safe money or all growth. Both layers serve a purpose. Safe money funds essential monthly expenses without exposure to market timing. Growth-oriented assets fight inflation and fund longer-term and discretionary needs.
The question worth asking: of your total expected monthly expenses in retirement, how much needs to be covered by income that cannot decline? The answer to that question determines how much of your retirement savings belongs in a protected layer.
Safe money is the buffer that protects a portfolio during a downturn — see what happens if the market drops and how much risk you are actually taking. It also shapes turning savings into income, and a major reason households keep a protected layer is the threat of long-term care costs.
Safe Money Is a Planning Layer, Not a Standalone Answer
Through our office, clients have access to a team of specialized financial advisors who have tailored training specific to common retirement accounts. They are built to work with folks 65+ navigating the transition from saving to spending. Determining how much of a retirement plan belongs in safe money, which options fit, and how they coordinate with investment accounts is the kind of analysis that benefits from a specialist who sees the full picture.
Find Out If a Safe Money Layer Fits Your Situation
A complimentary conversation looks at how much of your essential expenses needs protected income, which safe money options fit, and how they coordinate with the rest of your plan.
Michael Gurr is a Medicare and retirement specialist serving Pierce County and Western Washington.
Request a Free Retirement Review
Leave your information and Michael will reach out within one business day. No products pushed. No pressure — just clarity on what fits your situation.
Got it. You will hear from Michael soon.
Most responses arrive within one business day.